The third post in this series is titled “The Cons of Cutting Paint With Water (And This Is Where People Get Burned)”, the subsequent posts will build on this topic by talking about tools, techniques and related.  Enjoy the post and you can go back and read the others in this series.  If you enjoyed it, come and visit us on our social media: IG @martythepainter FB Marty’s Painters Tools

The Cons of Cutting Paint With Water (And This Is Where People Get Burned)

This is where things go wrong—fast.

Reduced coverage

Paint is engineered with a specific ratio of pigments, binders, and solids. Add too much water and you'll need extra coats to get coverage. That "saved" paint suddenly costs more time and labor. Paint coverage is determined by the volume of solids—the actual material that stays on the wall after the water evaporates. When you add water, you're not creating more solids, you're just spreading the same amount of pigment and binder across more square footage. A gallon that should cover 400 square feet might only cover 320 when thinned 20%. Now you need a third coat, which means more time, more material waste (you can't return opened paint), and more frustration.

Weaker durability

Over-thinned paint doesn't bond as well. It can scuff easier, wash poorly, and fail prematurely—especially in high-traffic areas. The binder in paint is what creates the film that protects the surface. When you dilute paint excessively, you're reducing the concentration of that binder relative to the area being covered. The result is a thinner, weaker paint film that's more susceptible to damage. High-touch areas like hallways, stairwells, and kids' rooms need full-strength paint. Thinning in these locations is asking for trouble within a year.

Inconsistent color

Dilution can change sheen and color depth, leading to uneven walls or visible touch-up marks later. This is particularly problematic with darker or more saturated colors. A wall painted with properly mixed paint and then touched up with thinned paint will show the repair—the color might match when wet but dry differently, or the sheen will be off. Deep reds, blues, and grays are especially unforgiving. Even worse, if you thin the first coat but not the second (or vice versa), you can end up with a mottled appearance that no amount of additional coats will fix.

Manufacturer warranty issues

Most paint manufacturers specify how much thinning (if any) is acceptable. Go beyond that and you're on your own if the paint fails. Paint companies spend millions developing their formulas and testing performance. When they say "do not thin more than 8 ounces per gallon," they mean it. If your paint peels, flakes, or fails to perform as advertised and you've exceeded their thinning guidelines, your warranty is void. That premium paint with the lifetime guarantee? It's now just expensive colored water with no manufacturer backing.

Runs and sagging

Thin paint moves. On vertical surfaces, that means drips, curtains, and extra cleanup. Gravity is undefeated, and overly thinned paint on a vertical surface will demonstrate this clearly. You'll see runs forming almost immediately, particularly on smooth surfaces like trim, doors, or previously painted walls with a semi-gloss finish. Catching and fixing runs is tedious work—you have to dab them out without creating more texture, then watch for them reforming as the paint continues to dry. On large walls, this can turn a straightforward paint job into an all-day monitoring session.

Poor hiding power

Thinned paint is more transparent. If you're covering a dark color with a light one, or dealing with stains and marks on the existing surface, diluted paint won't hide as effectively. What should have been a two-coat job becomes three or even four coats. This is especially problematic when painting over repaired drywall—the patches will show through, the texture differences become more visible, and you end up needing primer anyway, which defeats the purpose of thinning to save time or money.

Compromised stain resistance

Paint thickness contributes to stain resistance, particularly in kitchens and bathrooms. A properly applied coat of quality paint creates a barrier that resists moisture, cooking oils, and bathroom humidity. Thin that paint too much and you reduce its protective qualities. Water stains from condensation, grease marks near the stove, and soap scum in bathrooms will penetrate more easily and prove harder to clean.

‍